Skip to content The University of Alabama Where Legends Are Made
  • myBama
  • Students
  • Faculty & Staff
  • Alumni
  • Visitors
  • Apply
  • Give
  • A-Z Index
  • Catalog
  • News
  • Events
  • Directory
  • Map

Studying Religion in Culture

Ongoing Discussions at the University of Alabama

Main Navigation

The University of Alabama
  • Faculty Blog
  • Student Blog
  • Grad Blog
  • Guest Blog
  • American Examples
  • Class Blogs
  • Series
  • About
  • Apply
  • Visit
  • Give
  • myBama

Anything Goes?

September 11, 2016 by Russell McCutcheon

hebdoDo you recall the January 2015 shootings in France, at the offices of the satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo, and how, in response, people worldwide rallied to the cause of free speech, and its defining place in what many of us call Western culture, and thus the right of the French cartoonists to lampoon pretty much anything? Including the Prophet Mohammad — whether others liked it or not?

Well, have you seen this commercial from a San Antonio mattress store (that has since closed, apparently)?

Those of us interested in the study of religion — that is, those who are interested in how social groups define themselves by exercising strict control over boundaries and limits (a control that might go so far as to classify certain things as sacred, set apart, and inviolable) — would do well to mull over reactions to both of these cultural artifacts.

For the latter violates what many viewers might take as familiar and obviously set apart whereas the former violated only what others, elsewhere, largely unknown to many of us, seem to recognize as distinct and significant.

So will the mattress commercial elicit strong support for the store’s unfettered right to lampoon pretty much anything (while perhaps noting other people’s right not to shop there, to be sure) or, instead, will they be pretty much universally condemned for their crass insensitivity? Did they cross a line that’s too near to their prospective customers? And what constitutes the proper target of parody? For in the case of the Hebdo cartoons many of us agreed that pretty much anything goes. “I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it” — or so wrote Evelyn Beatrice Hall.

So what, if anything, makes the mattress commercial different? For my sense is that we will not see its parody so generously as we did Hebdo’s, and that we will not portray the principles involved in selling mattresses as being the very bedrock of freedom and democracy, as we did in the case of selling magazines.

Simply put, WWDS? (What would Durkheim say?)

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Faculty Blog
  • Relevance of Humanities
  • Religion in Culture
9-11 / Capitalism / Charlie Hebdo / Commerce / Emile Durkheim Social Formation / Sacred / Sales / September 11
Department of Religious Studies

Studying Religion in Culture

Welcome to the blog of the Department of Religious Studies at the University of Alabama. This site -- maintained by the faculty but also involving our students, our alumni, and the graduate teaching assistants who help us in our classes -- discusses the relevance of the study of religion, in particular, and the liberal arts, in general, for understanding both the past and present, by seeing religion as but one element of wider cultural practices.

Archives


Thematic Categories

  • Religion in Culture
  • Relevance of Humanities
  • Public Events

Recent Posts

  • What do you mean, “I don’t look like a religious studies major”?
  • The Power of Religious Language
  • Crafting a Warrior Idiom
  • Humans and Nazis: Reevaluating the Conversation of Us and Them 
  • In the Shadow of No Future: Justice Claims and the Israel-Palestine Conflict?

Recent Comments

  • Simon Wright on Simulation Theory: How is ‘Religion’ Part of It?
  • Torres Renoir on Top Ten Tips for Academic Blogging
  • gerard on Simulation Theory: How is ‘Religion’ Part of It?
  • Ashley on Making Sense of Debates on Harry Style’s Fashion with Religious Studies: Authority, Legitimation, and Authenticity
  • Lauren Thompson on Hunting Witches: a Social Constructivist Perspective

RSS feed


Follow Us on Twitter

My Tweets

Visit Us on Facebook

Visit Us on Facebook

Copyright © 2022 The University of Alabama (205) 348-6010 Contact UA

  • Accessibility
  • SACSCOC
  • Taskstream
  • Equal Opportunity
  • Data Access Request
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy
  • About This Site